Skip to primary navigationSkip to main contentSkip to footer
  • (614) 436-4653
  • 1 N Liberty St, Powell
  • Request an Appointment
  • Contact Us
Kimberly's Diamond Corner logo
  • Bridal
    Shop Bridal
    Engagement RingsComplete Engagement RingsEngagement Ring SettingsWomen's Wedding BandsMen's Wedding Bands
    Diamonds & Design
    Loose DiamondsBuild a RingCustom Engagement RingsCustom Gallery
    Plan Your Purchase
    Book an AppointmentReviewsThe 4Cs of DiamondsChoosing the Right Setting
    Menu image
  • Jewelry
    Shop by Category
    RingsNecklacesEarringsBraceletsPins & Brooches
    Popular Style
    Diamond StudsTennis BraceletsSolitaire JewelryStackable RingsBirthstone Jewelry
    Estate Jewelry
    RingsNecklacesEarringsBraceletsPins & Brooches
    More to Explore
    Charm JewelryAnkletsChainsMen's Jewelry
    Menu image
  • Custom
    Design & Build
    Custom Design ProcessBuild a RingRedesign Your Heirloom
    See Our Work
    Custom GalleryBook a Consultation
    Menu image
    Menu image
  • Services
    Repairs & Care
    Free Cleaning & InspectionJewelry RepairRing ResizingTip & Prong RepairRhodium Plating
    Watches & Extras
    Watch Battery ReplacementWatch RepairPearl & Bead RestringingJewelry Engraving
    Appraisals & Buying
    Jewelry AppraisalsJewelry InsuranceGold BuyingAntique & Estate RestorationNational Rarities Buying Events
    Menu image
  • Our Store
    Our Story
    Our Staff
    Reviews
    Jewelry Education
    Contact Us
    Menu image
    Menu image
  • Contact
  • (614) 436-4653
  • 1 N Liberty St, Powell
  • Request an Appointment
  • Contact Us
Kimberly's Diamond Corner logo
Log In
  • Toggle Search Menu
  • Toggle My Account Menu
    Login

    Don’t have an account? Sign up now

    Reset your password

    Enter the email address on your account and we’ll send you a recovery link.

    • My Account
    • Track My Order
    • Wishlist
    • Logout
  • Toggle My Wishlist
  • Toggle Shopping Cart Menu

Jewelry Insurance in Powell, Ohio

Protecting What You Wear Every Day

Many homeowners policies technically cover jewelry, but usually only up to a low limit, and often exclude things like a lost stone or a missing item without proof of theft. Jewelers Mutual is different: it's an insurer that specializes exclusively in jewelry, offering broader coverage for loss, theft, and accidental damage, and it lets you choose your own jeweler for repairs or replacement (so you can keep coming back to us).

Jewelry insurance requires a formal appraisal to get started. Chelsea, a graduate gemologist, does that right here in the store while you wait, so your coverage is based on real, current value.

Call 614-436-4653 Book an Appraisal

Why Your Homeowners Policy Is Probably Not Enough

Low sub limits

Homeowners and renters policies typically cap jewelry coverage at a modest amount, and that cap often applies to everything you own combined rather than to each piece. One ring can use up the entire limit.

Limited reasons for loss

Standard policies are often written around named perils such as fire and theft. Accidental loss, damage, and a ring that simply disappears are frequently where the gap shows up.

Your deductible applies

A homeowners deductible can be larger than the value of the piece you lost, which means a claim you technically have coverage for still pays you nothing.

Claims affect your home policy

Filing a jewelry claim against your homeowners policy can affect that policy going forward. A standalone jewelry policy keeps the two separate.

What a Jewelers Mutual Policy Covers

Jewelers Mutual writes what is called an all perils policy, which means loss, theft, damage, and disappearance are covered unless the policy specifically excludes them. Coverage applies to fine jewelry made with precious metals and gemstones, including rings, watches, bracelets, earrings, chains, pendants, brooches, pearl strands, and loose stones.

  • Loss
  • Theft
  • Damage
  • Disappearance
  • Natural disasters
  • Worldwide travel
  • Inflation protection
  • Preventive maintenance
  • Shipping

What is not covered

No policy covers everything, and it is better to know the exclusions now than during a claim. Jewelers Mutual generally does not cover loss or damage resulting from deterioration or a piece that was already weak or in disrepair, intentional acts, nuclear hazard, vermin or insect infestation, voluntary parting with the piece, war or military action, seizure by civil authority, or issues arising from resizing, cleaning, and inspection.

If you have a piece that needs repair, bring it to us first. Getting it sound before you insure it is the right order, and it is work we do here at our bench.

What It Costs

As a general rule, Jewelers Mutual states that coverage runs about 1 to 2 percent of the value of the piece per year. Where you land in that range depends mostly on where you live, and your deductible choice moves it as well. A higher deductible lowers the premium, and a lower deductible raises it.

1% to 2% of the value of the piece, per year, as a general guideline

Deductible options currently start at $0, with $100, $250, and $500 also available. Rates, discounts, and available options vary by state, so treat the numbers above as a way to set expectations rather than as a quote. Jewelers Mutual will give you an actual rate in a few minutes once they know what the piece is and where you live.

How to Get Covered

  1. Get an appraisal

    Make an appointment and bring your piece in. Chelsea appraises it here while you wait and you leave with the written document in hand. Insure for replacement value, meaning what it would cost to repair or replace the piece with one of the same kind and quality.

  2. Apply for coverage

    You can apply directly with Jewelers Mutual online or by phone. In most cases coverage begins the same day you apply and purchase. Their guidance is to insure as soon as a piece is in your possession, including before it goes back to the jeweler for sizing.

  3. Keep it current

    Gold and diamond values move. Jewelers Mutual recommends updating your appraisal every two years so you are neither underinsured nor paying premium on a value that is out of date. Stop in when you are due and we will take care of it.

If you ever do need to file a claim, Jewelers Mutual works directly with your jeweler rather than mailing you a check and wishing you luck. That means we can be the ones who repair or replace your piece, which is the whole point of buying from a store that has a bench.

Common Questions

Do I need to insure jewelry I did not buy from you?

No. Coverage has nothing to do with where a piece was purchased. We appraise and help with insurance for pieces bought anywhere, including inherited jewelry that has never been documented.

At what value is a separate policy worth it?

Jewelers Mutual suggests a standalone policy once a piece is worth roughly $1,500 or more, has real sentimental value, or would be a financial burden to replace. For most engagement rings, that is a yes.

Can I insure more than one piece?

Yes. There is no limit on the number of pieces you can cover, and each is rated individually. If you have several, calling Jewelers Mutual directly is usually faster than doing them one at a time online.

Who is eligible?

Coverage is available to people 18 and over living in the United States or Canada, with the exception of Quebec. The person who wears the jewelry needs to live in one of those places as well, and the piece should not be in need of repair when you apply.

Do you sell the policy here in the store?

We are not the insurer and we do not write the policy. What we do is the part that has to happen first and has to be done right, which is a credible appraisal from a graduate gemologist, plus honest answers about what your pieces are actually worth.

Start With an Appraisal

We are at 1 N Liberty Street in Powell, and we are the only full service jeweler in town, so you do not have to drive to Dublin or Columbus for this. Call us and we will find a time that works.

Call 614-436-4653 Request an Appointment

Please note: Kimberly's Diamond Corner is not an insurance agency and does not issue policies. Coverage, pricing, deductibles, discounts, eligibility, and terms are set by Jewelers Mutual and are subject to change. Everything on this page is a general summary offered to help you understand your options, and it is not a substitute for the actual policy language. Coverage options vary by state and by product, and exclusions and limitations may apply. Insurance coverage is subject to underwriting review and approval and to the actual policy terms and conditions. For current details, coverage specifics, and a rate, please visit jewelersmutual.com.

Information on this page is up to date as of August 12, 2026.

Shop
  • Engagement Rings
  • Wedding Bands
  • All Jewelry
  • Custom Design
  • Loose Diamonds
Store
1 North Liberty Street
Powell, OH 43065
(614) 436-4653
Store Information
Services
  • Free Cleaning & Inspection
  • Jewelry Repair
  • Ring Resizing
  • Tip & Prong Repair
  • Rhodium Plating
  • Watch Battery Replacement
  • Watch Repair
  • Pearl & Bead Restringing
  • Jewelry Appraisals
  • Gold & Diamond Buying
Our Store
  • Our Story
  • Reviews
  • Jewelry Education
  • Bridal
  • Custom Gallery
Get in Touch
  • Contact Us
  • Book an Appointment
  • Build a Ring
  • National Rarities Buying Events
  • Jewelry Insurance
Follow Us
  • Visit the gia website
  • Visit the jbt website
  • Visit the jewelers-mutual website
  • Visit the joa website
  • Visit the knot website
  • Return Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Accessibility Statement

© 2026 Kimberly's Diamond Corner. All Rights Reserved.

Powered by: Punchmark

My Cart
You have 0 items in your Cart.
Loading cart items
Loading

Learn how we use cookies in our Privacy Policy or manage cookie preferences.